In a discussion about Shulk in the Super Smash Bros. series today in the KoopaTV private Discord server, RawkHawk2010 asked me if Shulk's Monado Arts selection buff would increase his tier list position for Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. I said no, pros tend to mainly use Jump and Speed Monado Arts, and Shulk professionals are already very good about quickly button-mashing to the art they need. Then Rawk, feeling defeated about the prospect of Shulk rising in the competitive tier list, asked me if there is a tier list for casuals. I answered a flat “no”.
Over a decade ago, I wanted to try to make a casual tier list for Super Smash Bros. Melee and post it on the Nintendo NSider Forums. This never happened, because I gave up during my idea-formulation. How would I define the skill level of a casual? They obviously can't wavedash or L-cancel, but can they at least jump? Shield? Use up-b off the stage to recover? I've encountered a lot of players in Super Smash Bros. Brawl and Super Smash Bros. For Wii U's online modes who couldn't or wouldn't do any of those things, even with my helpful UPBRECOVER name-tag in the latter game. (And then demonstrating Up-B Recoveries, with their character, in front of them in the next match. Yeah, I try to be helpful to newbies.)
I remember Nintendo of America president Reggie Fils-Aime's pathetic performance versus Hungrybox in the Nintendo World Championships 2015 — Reggie literally didn't know how to use the jump button.
|Reggie lost this many stocks in only four minutes, and Hungrybox wasn't exactly trying.|
Should the casual tier list be based on players like Reggie?
The reason that a competitive tier list works is because it assumes the player is using the character to their maximum capability, essentially taking player skill out as a factor. It's rating characters at their peak known performance. (Players can always discover new things about a character and the metagame can change, and then a new tier list can be made.) It assumes a consistent, tournament-style ruleset. Consistent items (none), a certain selection of stages, number of stocks and so on.
A casual tier list, on the other hand, would be rating characters at their... minimum capacity, where it becomes much less about an individual character and more about basic gameplay fundamentals, which is a function of the player, not the character. Obviously, some characters are more newbie-friendly than others (Meta Knight in Super Smash Bros. Brawl is easier to use for a beginner than, say, the Ice Climbers). Would a casual tier list measure that?
If you assume a casual player has basic competence, what does that mean? They know how to play, yeah, but how aware are they of how they're spacing their attacks? Do they play safely? Do they try to condition their opponent? Are they predictable?
If we're talking about casuals, what is the ruleset being used? 1v1 For Glory? Free-for-all with Items on High? Are we measuring how good the Final Smashes are? Is it even a stock match?
Hopefully, you get the point. A real, competitive tier list assumes consistency. You can grade that. You can't grade an inconsistent mess that a casual tier list would have.
As for Shulk specifically, can we even assume a casual Shulk player would use his Monado Arts? Believe me, I've encountered Shulk players that don't use them at all. Some casual Shulk players do nothing but Back Slash and Vision... sometimes off the stage. And then they keep doing it, not thinking that they could be using much safer moves. ...Sadly, they'd probably still beat Reggie Fils-Aime in a fight of Super Smash Bros.
Ludwig hopes he has made his point pretty clear. Implicit in this article is a rejection of anyone who thinks that competitive tier lists somehow can't exist. If you would like to participate in private KoopaTV staff discussions, you'll have to become a part of the KoopaTV staff first. If that interests you, then this Hiring page should help answer your questions and get you started. You get to cut the long reader Requests queue by being part of the staff that creates the content on KoopaTV! (And you can answer your own questions!)